| 1 | | Primary 560b Evans City Rd | Butler |  US | | Everyone Goes To Pizza Joe's | N/A | Alex Kennedy | Athletics Assistant at Penn State New Kensington |
| 2 | | Primary 3324 Peachtree Road | Atlanta | US | | Atlanta Style Pizza | N/A | Sean Kelly | Managing Partner at Buckhead Pizza Co. |
| 3 | | Primary 2211 Woodward Avenue Avenue | Detroit | US | | Family. Fun. Pizza | N/A | james minchin | Owner |
| 4 | | Primary | Franklin | US | | "Gourmet Pizza Baked Fresh" | N/A | Khan Miller | Managing Partner at Crazy Italian Pizza |
| 5 | | Primary 1601 Hyland Ave | Kaukauna | US | | The Great Pizza Experience | N/A | Kevin Christie | Sales - Food Service & Education at Bernatello’s Foods |
| 6 | | Primary 1920 E 5th St | Tempe | US | | The Broccoli Crust Pizza People | N/A | Michaela Raner | Director of Marketing at Spinato's Fine Foods & Spinato's Pizzeria |
| 7 | | Primary 350 Saint Peter St | St Paul | US | | "Gimme A Slice of Pizza" | N/A | Mary Ward-Welisevich, MBA | N/A |
| 8 | | Primary 604 Sutter Street Suite 200 | Folsom | US | | The Tribute To Chicago Pizza | N/A | Stephanie Desrosiers | Bartender/Server at Chicago Fire |
| 9 | | Primary 3567 Alameda de las Pulgas | Menlo Park | US | | Serving Burgers-Brews-Pizza Since 1966 | N/A | Gregory Stern | Burgers-Brews-Pizza Since 1966 |
| 10 | | Primary 1805 MONROE ST | MADISON | US | | Pizza On A Mission | N/A | Scott Lynch | Serial Entrepreneur/DIY Specialist |
| 11 | | Primary 8515 W Overland RD | Boise | US | | It's All About The Pizza | N/A | Maureen Daniels | Bachelor's degree at Washington State University - Edward R. Murrow College of Communication |
| 12 | | Primary 3500 Harrison Ave | Butte | US | | Butte's Favorite Pizza Since 1969 | N/A | Cody Short | Partner at North Bank Vineyards |
| 13 | | Primary 110 Wisconsin Dells Parkway South | Wisconsin Dells | US | | The World's Only Moosejaw Pizza | N/A | Kirsten Hummel | Business Manager at Moosejaw Pizza and Dells Brewing Co |
| 14 | | Primary 624 S. Milledge Avenue (Suite 102) | Athens | US | | Express Your Inner Pizza | N/A | Michael Lonergan | Managing Partner at Georgia Oak Partners |
| 15 | | Primary 21021 Manessa Circle | Huntington Beach | US | | Hot, Fresh, Delicious Catered Pizza | N/A | N/A | N/A |
| 16 | | Primary 3324 Peachtree Road | Atlanta | US | | Atlanta Style Pizza | N/A | Sean Kelly | Managing Partner at Buckhead Pizza Co. |
| 17 | | Primary 5601 Executive Drive Ste 125 | Irving | US | | Never Trust A Round Pizza | N/A | Charles Ballard | V.P. Franchise Development at i Fratelli Pizza |
| 18 | | Primary 30300 Stephenson Hwy. #200 | Madison Heights | US | | Originators of Flavored Crust Pizza | N/A | bronko nagurski | Owner |
| 19 | | Primary 1200 Station Dr. Ste. 150 | DuPont | US | | Great People Make Great Pizza | N/A | Clayton Krueger | Director of Marketing and Communications at Farrelli's Pizza |
| 20 | | Primary 16990 monterey st, #120 | morgan hill | US | | Pizza. Wings. Salads. Breadstix | N/A | N/A | N/A |
